feat: encode ai review outcome in commit marker

README.md

@@ -33,9 +33,9 @@
 2. 在 `.gitea/workflows` 資料夾中建立 `ai-review.yaml'
 3. 在 `ai-review.yaml` 中填入以下內容(選擇一個使用)：
 
-> **自動提交排除說明**：此 Action 會將自己的 commit message 標記為 `[ai-review-bot]`，而且 action 執行時會先透過 Gitea API 檢查這次觸發的 PR head commit（優先用 `pull_request.head.sha`）是否含有這個 marker，若有就直接成功結束，避免 bot commit 造成重複觸發。若外層 workflow 也能先檢查一次，效果最好。
+> **自動提交排除說明**：此 Action 會將自己的 commit message 標記為 `[ai-review-bot][success]` 或 `[ai-review-bot][failure]`，而且 action 執行時會先透過 Gitea API 檢查這次觸發的 PR head commit（優先用 `pull_request.head.sha`）是否含有這個 marker，若有就直接成功結束，避免 bot commit 造成重複觸發。若外層 workflow 也能先檢查一次，效果最好。
 
-> **權限說明**：此 Action 需要 `contents: write`（寫入 findings.json）、`pull-requests: write`（發佈 PR comment）、`issues: write`（發佈 issue comment）、以及 commit status 寫入權限，為正常運作所必要，無法縮減。
+> **權限說明**：此 Action 需要 `contents: write`（寫入 findings.json）、`pull-requests: write`（發佈 PR comment）、`issues: write`（發佈 issue comment）三項權限，為正常運作所必要，無法縮減。
 
 ### 1. OpenAI
 ```yaml

app/git.js

@@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ export function cloneRepo(workspace, _spawnSync = spawnSync) {
   });
 }
 
-export async function commitAndPush(workspace, repoDir, _spawnSync = spawnSync, sourceRoot = ACTION_ROOT) {
+export async function commitAndPush(workspace, repoDir, _spawnSync = spawnSync, sourceRoot = ACTION_ROOT, reviewOutcome = 'success') {
   const run = makeRunner(_spawnSync);
 
   try {
@@ -134,13 +134,14 @@ export async function commitAndPush(workspace, repoDir, _spawnSync = spawnSync,
         return;
       }
 
-      const out = run(['commit', '-m', `chore: update ai-review findings ${BOT_COMMIT_MARKER}`], repoDir);
+      const outcomeTag = reviewOutcome === 'failure' ? '[failure]' : '[success]';
+      const out = run(['commit', '-m', `chore: update ai-review findings ${BOT_COMMIT_MARKER}${outcomeTag}`], repoDir);
       const commitHash = out.match(/\[.+ ([a-f0-9]+)\]/)?.[1] || 'unknown';
       try {
         run(['push', remoteUrl, PR_HEAD_BRANCH], repoDir, credEnv);
-        console.log(`  ✅ persisted findings  commit=${commitHash}  push=${PR_HEAD_BRANCH}`);
+        console.log(`  ✅ persisted findings  commit=${commitHash}  push=${PR_HEAD_BRANCH} review_outcome=${reviewOutcome}`);
       } catch (pushErr) {
-        console.log(`  ⚠️  Step7 commit 成功但 push 失敗: commit=${commitHash} push=${PR_HEAD_BRANCH} error=${pushErr.message}`);
+        console.log(`  ⚠️  Step7 commit 成功但 push 失敗: commit=${commitHash} push=${PR_HEAD_BRANCH} review_outcome=${reviewOutcome} error=${pushErr.message}`);
       }
     });
   } catch (e) {

app/git.test.js

@@ -67,6 +67,17 @@ describe('commitAndPush', () => {
     const commitCall = spawn.calls.find(c => c.args[0] === 'commit');
     assert.ok(commitCall, 'expected git commit to run');
     assert.ok(commitCall.args.some(arg => arg.includes(BOT_COMMIT_MARKER)), 'expected commit message to include bot marker');
+    assert.ok(commitCall.args.some(arg => arg.includes('[success]')), 'expected commit message to include success outcome');
+  });
+
+  it('tags failed reviews with the failure outcome marker', async () => {
+    const spawn = makeSpawn();
+    await commitAndPush(workspace, path.join(workspace, 'repo'), spawn, sourceRoot, 'failure');
+
+    const commitCall = spawn.calls.find(c => c.args[0] === 'commit');
+    assert.ok(commitCall, 'expected git commit to run');
+    assert.ok(commitCall.args.some(arg => arg.includes(BOT_COMMIT_MARKER)), 'expected commit message to include bot marker');
+    assert.ok(commitCall.args.some(arg => arg.includes('[failure]')), 'expected commit message to include failure outcome');
   });
 
   it('uses GIT_ASKPASS env for network operations (fetch, push, clone)', async () => {

app/gitea.js

@@ -13,6 +13,11 @@ function extractCommitMessage(payload) {
     || '';
 }
 
+export function getBotReviewOutcome(message) {
+  const match = String(message || '').match(/\[ai-review-bot\](?:\[(success|failure)\])?/i);
+  return match?.[1]?.toLowerCase() || 'unknown';
+}
+
 /**
  * 取得 PR 的 Git Diff 內容，已自動排除 .gitea/ 資料夾。
  */
@@ -71,7 +76,7 @@ export async function shouldSkipBotCommit({ sha = PR_HEAD_SHA || process.env.GIT
 
   const shaMessage = await getCommitMessageBySha(sha);
   if (sha) {
-    console.log(`  🔎 bot-check: sha=${sha} message=${shaMessage ? 'found' : 'empty'}`);
+    console.log(`  🔎 bot-check: sha=${sha} message=${shaMessage ? 'found' : 'empty'} outcome=${getBotReviewOutcome(shaMessage)}`);
     if (shaMessage.includes('[ai-review-bot]')) {
       console.log('  ✅ bot-check: matched commit sha marker');
       return true;
@@ -82,7 +87,7 @@ export async function shouldSkipBotCommit({ sha = PR_HEAD_SHA || process.env.GIT
 
   const branchMessage = await getBranchHeadCommitMessage(branch);
   if (branch) {
-    console.log(`  🔎 bot-check: branch=${branch} head_message=${branchMessage ? 'found' : 'empty'}`);
+    console.log(`  🔎 bot-check: branch=${branch} head_message=${branchMessage ? 'found' : 'empty'} outcome=${getBotReviewOutcome(branchMessage)}`);
     if (branchMessage.includes('[ai-review-bot]')) {
       console.log('  ✅ bot-check: matched branch head marker');
       return true;
@@ -95,24 +100,6 @@ export async function shouldSkipBotCommit({ sha = PR_HEAD_SHA || process.env.GIT
   return false;
 }
 
-export async function setCommitStatus(sha, state, description, context = 'ai-review/critical', targetUrl = '') {
-  if (!sha) throw new Error('commit sha is required for status update');
-  const payload = {
-    state,
-    context,
-    description,
-  };
-  if (targetUrl) payload.target_url = targetUrl;
-
-  const resp = await axios.post(api(`/repos/${GITEA_REPOSITORY}/statuses/${encodeURIComponent(sha)}`), payload, {
-    headers: headers(),
-    timeout: 30000,
-    httpsAgent,
-  });
-  console.log(`  ✅ status: sha=${sha} state=${state} context=${context} description=${description}`);
-  return resp.data;
-}
-
 /**
  * 過濾 diff 內容，移除路徑符合 excludePrefixes 的區塊。
  * 每個區塊以 "diff --git a/<prefix>" 開頭判斷，使用 startsWith 精確比對前綴。

app/gitea.test.js

@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 import { describe, it, afterEach, mock } from 'node:test';
 import assert from 'node:assert/strict';
 import axios from 'axios';
-import { getPRDiff, filterDiff, postComment, getCommitMessageBySha, getBranchHeadCommitMessage, shouldSkipBotCommit, setCommitStatus } from './gitea.js';
+import { getPRDiff, filterDiff, postComment, getCommitMessageBySha, getBranchHeadCommitMessage, shouldSkipBotCommit, getBotReviewOutcome } from './gitea.js';
 
 afterEach(() => mock.restoreAll());
 
@@ -86,7 +86,7 @@ describe('gitea', () => {
   it('shouldSkipBotCommit returns true when either sha or branch head is bot commit', async () => {
     mock.method(axios, 'get', async (url) => {
       if (url.includes('/git/commits/sha-bot')) {
-        return { data: { message: 'chore: update ai-review findings [ai-review-bot]' } };
+        return { data: { message: 'chore: update ai-review findings [ai-review-bot][failure]' } };
       }
       if (url.includes('/branches/feat%2Ftest')) {
         return { data: { commit: { id: 'sha-bot' } } };
@@ -94,25 +94,9 @@ describe('gitea', () => {
       return { data: { message: 'regular commit' } };
     });
     await assert.equal(await shouldSkipBotCommit({ sha: 'sha-bot', branch: 'feat/test' }), true);
-  });
+    assert.equal(getBotReviewOutcome('chore: update ai-review findings [ai-review-bot][failure]'), 'failure');
-
+    assert.equal(getBotReviewOutcome('chore: update ai-review findings [ai-review-bot][success]'), 'success');
-  it('setCommitStatus posts commit status to Gitea API', async () => {
+    assert.equal(getBotReviewOutcome('chore: update ai-review findings [ai-review-bot]'), 'unknown');
-    let capturedUrl, capturedBody, capturedOpts;
-    mock.method(axios, 'post', async (url, body, opts) => {
-      capturedUrl = url;
-      capturedBody = body;
-      capturedOpts = opts;
-      return { data: { state: body.state } };
-    });
-
-    const result = await setCommitStatus('sha-123', 'failure', 'found 2 critical issues', 'ai-review/critical', 'https://example.com/pr/1');
-    assert.equal(result.state, 'failure');
-    assert.ok(capturedUrl.includes('/statuses/sha-123'));
-    assert.equal(capturedBody.state, 'failure');
-    assert.equal(capturedBody.context, 'ai-review/critical');
-    assert.equal(capturedBody.description, 'found 2 critical issues');
-    assert.equal(capturedBody.target_url, 'https://example.com/pr/1');
-    assert.ok(capturedOpts.headers['Authorization'].startsWith('token '));
   });
 });
 

app/main.js

@@ -1,22 +1,13 @@
 import path from 'path';
-import { GITEA_REPOSITORY, GITEA_SERVER_URL, PR_NUMBER, PR_HEAD_BRANCH, PR_BASE_BRANCH, getLLMConfig, FINDINGS_PATH, EXCLUSIONS_PATH } from './config.js';
+import { GITEA_REPOSITORY, PR_NUMBER, PR_HEAD_BRANCH, PR_BASE_BRANCH, getLLMConfig, FINDINGS_PATH, EXCLUSIONS_PATH } from './config.js';
 import { loadRoles, getRoleIntro } from './roles.js';
-import { getPRDiff, postComment, shouldSkipBotCommit, setCommitStatus } from './gitea.js';
+import { getPRDiff, postComment, shouldSkipBotCommit } from './gitea.js';
 import { analyzeWithRole, loadOldFindings, mergeFindings, sortByLevel, deduplicateWithAI, loadExclusions, applyExclusions, filterFalsePositivesWithAI } from './findings.js';
 import { saveFindings, postOldFindingsComment, postNewNonCriticalComment, postNewCriticalComments } from './comments.js';
 import { cloneRepo, commitAndPush, getRepoState } from './git.js';
 import { validateJSONArrayFile, ensureJSONArrayFileExists } from './json.js';
 
 const WORKSPACE = process.env.GITHUB_WORKSPACE || '/workspace';
-const REVIEW_STATUS_CONTEXT = 'ai-review/critical';
-
-async function updateReviewStatus(sha, criticalCount) {
-  const state = criticalCount > 0 ? 'failure' : 'success';
-  const description = criticalCount > 0
-    ? `found ${criticalCount} critical issue${criticalCount === 1 ? '' : 's'}`
-    : 'no critical issues found';
-  await setCommitStatus(sha, state, description, REVIEW_STATUS_CONTEXT, `${GITEA_SERVER_URL.replace(/\/$/, '')}/${GITEA_REPOSITORY}/pulls/${PR_NUMBER}`);
-}
 
 async function main() {
   console.log('='.repeat(60));
@@ -26,17 +17,6 @@ async function main() {
 
   if (await shouldSkipBotCommit()) {
     console.log('  🤖 偵測到 [ai-review-bot] 自動提交，直接完成 action');
-    let criticalCount = 0;
-    try {
-      const repoDir = cloneRepo(WORKSPACE);
-      const findings = loadOldFindings(repoDir || WORKSPACE);
-      criticalCount = findings.filter(f => f.level === 'critical').length;
-      console.log(`  🔎 bot-check: current findings critical=${criticalCount}`);
-      await updateReviewStatus(process.env.PR_HEAD_SHA || process.env.GITHUB_SHA, criticalCount);
-    } catch (e) {
-      console.error(`  ❌ bot-check: 無法回報 status: ${e.message}`);
-      process.exit(1);
-    }
     console.log('='.repeat(60));
     process.exit(0);
   }
@@ -62,7 +42,6 @@ async function main() {
 
   if (!diff.trim()) {
     console.log('  ⚠️  diff 為空，無需審查');
-    await updateReviewStatus(process.env.PR_HEAD_SHA || process.env.GITHUB_SHA, 0);
     process.exit(0);
   }
 
@@ -149,12 +128,13 @@ async function main() {
 
   // Step7: commit/push findings.json 到來源分支
   console.log('\n💾 Step7: 記憶區 Commit/Push');
-  await commitAndPush(WORKSPACE, repoDir || WORKSPACE);
+  const reviewOutcome = filtered.some(f => f.level === 'critical') ? 'failure' : 'success';
+  console.log(`  🔎 review outcome=${reviewOutcome}`);
+  await commitAndPush(WORKSPACE, repoDir || WORKSPACE, undefined, undefined, reviewOutcome);
 
   // Step9: 有 critical 問題則 exit 1
   console.log('\n🚦 Step8: 嚴重問題檢查');
   const criticalCount = filtered.filter(f => f.level === 'critical').length;
-  await updateReviewStatus(process.env.PR_HEAD_SHA || process.env.GITHUB_SHA, criticalCount);
   if (criticalCount > 0) {
     console.log(`  ❌ 發現 ${criticalCount} 個嚴重問題，workflow 結束（exit 1）`);
     console.log('='.repeat(60));